APPOINTMENT OF AUDITOR

Penny was Guilford’s Treasurer and Town Clerk for 12 years. When she retired, the Selectboard proposed a ballot initiative to Appoint the next Treasurer instead of the Town Electing a new one.

​

At the same time, the Selectboard, lead by Chairman Eastes, and Guilford's Finance advisory Committee, lead by Chairwoman Sheila Morse, also proposed that the Elected Town Clerk’s budget be reduced, and the Appointed Treasurer and Town Administrator budgets be increased.

​

At the all-in-person Town Meeting, Guilford voters approved the the Selectboard's proposal to appoint the next Treasurer and their budget recommendations for all offices.

​

Penny’s retirement then created issues with the separation of offices in Guilford. Since the Clerks budget was decreased, she reduced her hours. The appointed Treasurer and Town Administrator, with increased budgets, wanted access to the vaults when the Town Clerk wasn’t there.

 

The Town Clerk controls the vaults, and Penny combined Treasurer and Town Clerk documents in both Vaults.

​

​This issue led to the takeover of Guilford’s Town Vaults which, “Friends and Election Integrity,” explains in detail.

​

When Penny retired, residents were particularly concerned about the transition from their Elected Treasurer of 12 years to Guilford’s first Selectboard appointed Treasurer. Much like a retail store clerk “cashing out” at the end of their shift, residents wanted a clear break between Penny and the new Treasurer.  

 

So, the residents gathered signatures for a ballot article asking the voters of Guilford to consider a type of forensic audit.

 

After gathering almost twice the signatures required and presenting them to the selectboard, Chairman Eastes and Town Administrator Morse orchestrated the selectboard’s denial of that petition.  

 

Role of an Elected Auditor

​

Chairman Eastes has claimed repeatedly that Vermont statute doesn’t require Elected Auditors to perform their statatory duties as described in the VLCT Selectboard Handbook. He claims that the selectboard’s hired professional auditors perform that function and Guilford's elected auditors are simply editors of the Town Report.

​

Guilford resident Tammy Sargent See Friends and the FAC challenged Eastes’ position on the elected auditor’s role and wrote a letter to the entire selectboard asking for a public hearing on the topic. Tammy's request for a hearing was denied but Eastes chose to publicly discredit the 2008 version of the VLCT handbook Tammy submitted.

​​

Referring to the 2008 Auditor’s Handbook, that Tammy presented the Selectboard, Chairman Eastes stated that the “VLCT doesn’t make them anymore,” and then claimed that “they no longer produce those sorts of handbooks, for a number of reasons.” 

​

Jason Herron then posted the 2022 version of the VLCT’s Auditor’s Handbook in the chat function of the selectboard meeting which directly conflicted with Zon’s statements. At the following selectboard meeting, Zon had the chat function removed.

​

Residents were now inquiring if the Elected Auditors were performing their statutory duties. Where they acting, as the VLCT handbook describes, as the “Watchdogs of Town Finance" OR were they simply relying on the information the Selectboard's "staff" was feeding them?

​

 Guilford’s Newly Appointed Auditor

​

On April 5, 2024, one of Guilford’s Elected Auditors resigned. Following that resignation, two Guilford residents, Tammy Sargent and Lyndsey Mitchell, offered their services.

​

Remember, Zon was appointed by the selectboard after only 2 weeks. (The time between regular selectboard meetings) Instead of appointing either of those qualified women “forthwith,” (immediately; without delay) as Vermont Statute § 963 requires, Chairman Eastes offered another option.

​

One month after Tammy and Lyndsey submitted their interest, Zon motioned for the selectboard to “define the process.” (seek another candidate) That vote delayed the appointment of anyone while the town administrator created a new “job description.” Following interviews, the board would make their appointment on June 24th.

​

Just days before the new deadline, Robert Tucker submitted his “Letter of Interest” in the Auditors vacancy to the town administrator. It reads in part:

I am writing to express my interest in the open Auditor position. (…) I started that position [Bob was a previous town auditor] shortly after the Town moved to (…) professional auditors, (…). Back then, we (…) left the audit to the professionals. (…). Over the years, we did less actual auditing (…)

​

In terms of my resume, I worked for Crofter Moving and Storage for 20 years. (…) After that, I transitioned to my own freelance bookkeeping business, (…).

 

I have been involved with many area businesses and nonprofits (two of which, “Brattleboro Music Center” (...) Which was "run by Zon Eastes, your current Selectboard Chair, who can serve as a reference.)"

​

I have never conducted an audit, (…) I do not have any college degree, (…).

​

Respectfully submitted for your consideration, Robert Tucker​​

​

With Tucker's application, there were now three people for the Selectboard to choose from. Lyndsey is an Enrolled Agent with the IRS who owns a registered bookkeeping business. Tammy was on Guilford's Finance Advisory Committee and had been critical of recent discoveries concerning the Capital, Reserve, and Waterline Funds. Lastly, there is Robert Tucker whose qualifications were just disclosed.

​

At 55:40, Selectboard member Tara Cheney stated their decision to choose Bob Tucker over Lyndsey and Tammy “was based on who has the most experience in auditing accounting and bookkeeping, Bob has performed over 750 thousand audits multiple times.”

 

Wait, what? Bob's letter to the Town Administrator clearly states he has "never performed an audit," and he was a "freelance bookkeeper" for the Chairman's nonprofit, the "Brattleboro Music Center," which was yoked to Zeke and Linda Hecker​ for decades.

 

To add, Chairman Eastes should have disclosed his relationship and recused himself. Insted, Zon voted for his former employee to become Guilford's Town Auditor. 

 

BTW, Bob's Wife sits as the Chairwoman of the Guilford Library Board of Trustees. 

​